In April 2026 Mr. Garcha KC and Mr. Jarmola’s client was sentenced by a High Court Judge to a determinate period of seven years’ detention, for the offence of manslaughter by reason of loss of control. The defendant was acquitted by the jury of murder. The Solicitor General, represented by Senior Treasury King’s Counsel, argued that the sentence imposed was unduly lenient, and that a term of detention in the region of fourteen years’ detention was appropriate.
Mr. Garcha KC argued that the extremely experienced sentencing Judge had correctly categorised the offending within the relevant guideline and, furthermore, had properly accounted for and carefully applied all relevant aggravating and mitigating factors when passing sentence. None of the findings made by the learned Judge were arguably flawed or unreasonable, there simply was no gross error within the sentencing process and conclusions.
The Court of Appeal agreed with Mr. Garcha KC, finding that the sentence imposed was “commendably lenient” on the basis of the facts of the case as were highlighted by Mr. Garcha KC in his submissions, and refused the Solicitor General’s application for leave to appeal.
Read the case summary from April 2026, here.
Mr. Garcha KC and Justin Jarmola were instructed by Arun Deane, of 1 Law Solicitors, 12 Caroline Street, Birmingham, B3 1TR.